Before we get started…
My partners and I have enrollment open for business owners who want a Scalable Operating System installed before the end of the year.
If you want to get started this year, now's the time. Once December hits, most new applications roll into a January start.
Our goal is to get you unstuck and out of the "day-to-day" before the holiday craziness takes over (including the "what can we afford to pay in bonuses?" guessing game…more on that in a minute), finish 2026 strong...
…and set up to make 2027 your best year ever.
Ok, onto this week's article…
"My team keeps asking about year-end bonuses, and I have no idea what we can afford."
A few clients have asked me about year-end bonuses lately (probably because their employees are asking them).
If your people are asking you, too, then you need to get it right…
If you guess high, you'll drain the cash you need in January.
If you guess low, your best people will notice.
I've made the first mistake.
I once had to write a personal check to cover a profit-share bonus while the business was hemorrhaging cash.
My team was thrilled!
The problem? My poor planning had just put their jobs at risk.
So you don't just want to pick a number based on gut feel or the need to be "liked" and "do the right thing."
That's why we created the Profit-First Bonus Pool. It works whether you've had a bonus plan for years or you're deciding this December for the first time.
Here's how it works…
SIDE NOTE: We also built a free calculator that does the math for you: the IncentiveWise Planner.
Step 1: Set Your Profit Trigger
Your Profit Trigger is how much profit the business has to keep in its piggy bank (to cover non-P&L obligations) before a single dollar goes into the bonus pool. That includes:
Tax savings
Debt payments
Your emergency reserve
Money set aside for the big, planned expenses coming next year
And yes, your own distributions
Not understanding this is exactly how I wound up writing that personal check.
Here's how to find it: Look back at your last 12 months and add up what it actually took to cover those obligations. If I'd done that simple, back-of-the-napkin math, I would have realized I needed about $250,000 a quarter ($1M a year) to cover everything, including my own distributions.
So if your number is $250,000 a quarter, bonuses kick in at $250,001…not a penny before.
(If you don't have those obligations set aside in their own accounts yet, here's how we structure them.)
Step 2: Size the Pool
Now take your profit for the year, subtract your Profit Trigger, and decide what share of what's left goes to the team.
10-20% is a healthy, typical range. Some companies go as high as 50%, depending on how many people are in the pool and what other cash obligations they're carrying.
Then sanity-check it against your people: a motivating bonus usually adds 5-15% on top of someone's base pay. (It can be much higher for leadership roles with big variable comp plans.)
In other words, you want it big enough to be motivating, but not so big that it throws someone's pay way out of whack with the market.
For example: Let's say your business made $1.2M in profit this year, and your Profit Trigger is $250,000 a quarter ($1M a year).
That leaves $200,000 above the trigger, and if 20% of that goes to the team, you've got a $40,000 bonus pool.
Now split it across a team of six people who average $60,000 in base pay. That's about $6,700 each, or about 11% on top of base pay…right in the 5-15% range.
Step 3: Pick a Payout Method
Next, decide how the pool gets divided. There's no single right answer here (different companies do it differently), but there are four common options:
% of Wage: Higher pay = bigger share. (This is the most common.)
Equal Payout: Everyone in the pool gets the same amount. (Best for small, flat teams.)
Share-Based: Works like phantom equity. Let's say there are 1,000 "shares" in the pool, and each person gets shares based on tenure or performance. Each share is worth 1/1,000th of the pool.
Hybrid: Some combination of the above, like 60% by wage and 40% equal, so you reward both individual contribution and team cohesion.
Pick the one that fits your team, then write it down.
IMPORTANT: Don't Wait Until Next December
Once you've run this math, don't wait 12 months to run it again.
We typically pay bonuses quarterly, because monthly is too choppy and too much admin work, and annual is just too far away to be motivating the first half of the year.
And each quarter we hold back 20% of what's available for distribution and pay out the rest.
That 20% holdback each quarter buys you two things:
A cushion for profit dips later in the year
A bigger payout at year end, which also gives people thinking about leaving a reason to stick around for that final check (a.k.a. their year-end bonus).
We've seen this small tweak reduce regrettable turnover by 30% at some of the companies we work with.
Run this math once a quarter (starting THIS quarter), and you won't have to guess what you'll be able to afford next December.
⚡️ Action Step: This week, build your Profit-First Bonus Pool. Pull your last 12 months of numbers and figure out your Profit Trigger (what it really takes to cover taxes, debt, reserves, planned expenses, and your own distributions). Then subtract it from this year's profit, pick a percentage you could defend to your team, and plug both into the IncentiveWise Planner before you announce a single number.
Give it a shot and let me know how it goes…
-Ryan
Ryan Deiss
Co-Founder and CEO, The Scalable Company
P.S. A bonus pool only works when the numbers live in a system instead of your head.
That's exactly what a Scalable Operating System fixes…
…and my partners and I have enrollment open for business owners who want one installed before the end of the year.
If you want to start in 2026, apply now, because once December hits, most new applications roll into a January start.
Quick Hits
The best of what I read, watched, and clicked this week…
📈 Growth
From 8 employees to 400, and the expensive mistakes he'd undo (Owned & Operated)
Nobody noticed that 32% of this distributor's customers were unprofitable (Contrarian Thinking)
💰 Money
He turned down 20x EBITDA and sold for 32x (Built to Sell Radio)
PepsiCo wrote Poppi's $300M earn-out down to $12M, and the founders still came out ahead (Business Lunch)
He skipped the bootstrap and went from $20K to $80K a month (Acquiring Minds)
Cereal price wars and the percent-of-profit question nobody asks (Girdley's Letter)
⚙️ Systems & Ops
🛠️ Tools & AI
24 questions that show you where your week actually goes (CEO Time Audit)
One weekly view of the numbers your decisions actually hang on (CEO Dashboard)
Give Claude and ChatGPT a marketing brain that already knows your customers, offers, and voice (DigitalMarketer Genesis)


